Humankind - A Hopeful History by Rutger Bregman

Sue Cartwright • Oct 13, 2022

A book that celebrates the innate goodness of human beings

Humankind - A Hopeful History by Rutger Bregman


It's hard to find books in bookshops that celebrate the innate goodness of human nature and the inherent ingenuity and resourcefulness of human beings. This is why this book is a rare treat and why I am keen to share its extensive findings.

 

Why this book?

 

It's true that certain books appear when it's the right time to read them.

 

I bought Humankind over a year ago, put it on my bookshelf and promised to get back to it - having been enticed by the heartwarming testimonials on the back cover together with the catchline: 'How would your life and view of the world change if you knew people were good?' 

 

It was only when I moved house a few weeks ago that I picked it up again and knew it was being presented to me as one of those books that I need to read now. I did so with relish as it turned out and I am delighted to share these insights with you here.

 

What is it about?

 

Humankind is a well written and researched book by historian and writer, Rutger Bregman, who lives in Holland. Rutger challenges the notion that 'civilisation is no more than skin deep' by exposing the myth that by nature, human beings are selfish, aggressive and quick to panic.

 

Nothing, in fact, could be farther from the truth, and claiming this as such on the back of spurious research and manipulated experiments, is a tactic known as Veneer Theory identified by a Dutch biologist, Frans de Waal.

 

There are examples of Veneer Theory throughout the book demonstrating that claims presenting a wholly negative and unpleasant view of human nature as a basis for government policy and so on are not only untrue but dangerous for humanity as a whole.

 

The result of this misconception we see all around us today, and as a sweet antidote, Rutger provides many opposing stories and 'hidden' bona fide research proving the opposite of these false claims to be true.

 

What is the main premise?

 

Humankind presents a radical idea that most people, deep down, are pretty decent. It poses the question of what kind of planet we would prefer to live on (in the context of what people might do in the event of a plane crash). Would it be: A - where people help those needing assistance out of the plane first, showing a willingness to give their life for perfect strangers, or B - where people panic and fend for themselves, trampling those in need of assistance under foot.

 

Rutger makes the case that although 97 per cent of people think we live on Planet B, in almost every case, we actually live on Planet A. The sinking of the Titanic provides a good example when the block-buster film is compared to what actually happened in the most terrifying of situations. Far from the dramatised panic, people were in fact quite orderly and considerate, working together and helping those most in need of assistance first.

 

Block-buster films, books and documentaries that falsify tragic events like these, presenting them as real-life stories, are a clear example of Veneer Theory being used to mislead people about the fundamental and benevolent tenets of human nature.

 

What are the main points discussed?

 

Humankind begins with two intriguing stories that demonstrate Veneer Theory in action leaving no question of its validity in terms of the difference between what goes on and what we are told about these things.  One of these stories is so wonderful and powerful, I am writing a separate post about it.

 

This is followed by five sections as follows: where we are now (The State of Nature); the impact of two World Wars (after Auschwitz); how power corrupts (Why Good People Turn Bad); and how we treat each other (The Other Cheek).

 

The Epilogue presents '10 Rules to Live By' which are helpful in framing a positive state of mind. These simple rules align very much with our values and encourage us all to be kind to ourselves and each other which is what humanity needs most right now.

 

These are my favourite rules which I think we could all benefit from during such turbulent times:

 

  • When in doubt, assume the best
  • Think in win-win scenarios
  • Ask more questions
  • Temper your empathy, train your compassion
  • Try to understand the other, even if you don't get where they're coming from
  • Come out of the closet, don't be ashamed to do good
  • Avoid the news (and other mainstream media)

 

What are the key highlights?

 

The aim here (and in all our Book Insights) is to shine a light on good news and accredited knowledge that has until now been hidden from sight, dismissed or ridiculed by design.

 

This book contains a great deal of good news for humankind with some examples as follows:

 

New kids on the block

An all new and improved version of the Lord of the Flies completely debunks the idea that children left alone to survive and look after themselves on a desert island results in rivalry and carnage. This entirely made-up story was heavily publicised at the time and went viral. The danger lies in these fictional stories being translated into unproven, pseudo 'facts' about human nature and we can see the long-term effects of this deception all around us today.

 

By way of comparison, Rutger presents a little known incident of a group of real boys who were deserted on an island for over a year which led to an altogether different outcome. It is a truly heartwarming story and one that deserves its own post which I will share as another book insight soon.

 

Men against fire

Our impressions of what happens in wars turns out to be a misconception and puts the business of fighting wars into an entirely different perspective. Numerous accounts come to the conclusion that most soldiers never fired their guns and that fear of aggression appears to be the normal part of our emotional make-up. For example, most soldiers would aim too high to avoid killing their fellow man whatever side they were fighting for with practically all the injuries and fatalities being caused by other means.

 

Christmas between the lines 

I think we are all aware of the remarkable morale shown by war torn victims on both sides of the equation during the war, in particular the London and Dresden bombings. I wasn't aware of a similarly endearing story about the English and the Germans dropping their weapons on the front lines and coming together to celebrate Christmas together, sharing cigarettes and chocolate, showing each other photographs of their loved ones and wondering what they were all doing there and what they were fighting for.

 

I can't imagine what the conditions must have been like and it's another clear example of what human beings are truly made of.

 

Managing [people] is bullsh**

This is interesting, especially as we move closer to the time when we need to be managing ourselves and not others or each other. I know from my staff motivation survey facilitation days that when people have all the information they need to make informed decisions, the training they need to learn what they need to know, the resources they need to carry out their work to a high standard with support available if required, they do not need to be managed. Indeed, being micro-managed is recognised as being highly demotivating, having a negative impact on job satisfaction.

 

A good example of this is provided with the story of Jos de Blok who built a highly successful healthcare organisation by simply 'letting people do their job.'

 

This completely throws the capitalist/communism idea of having to use a carrot and stick approach out of the window. It also knocks Frederick Taylor's idea on the head that workers need enforced supervision from management and that 'what they want most from their employers, beyond anything else, is high wages.'


Where most corporate employers seem to be cut off from the real world in this regard, Jos sees his employees as 'intrinsically motivated professionals and experts who have no need for managers.'

 

It is true that the greater the autonomy for everyone involved, the greater the win-win-win situation for employer, employee and the organisation as a whole.

 

Made to believe (make-believe)

This is the exposure and significance of famous experiments which were designed and manipulated (sometimes to horrific degrees) to bring out the worst in people. These include 'The Prison Experiment' in Stanford University's basement and the Stanley Milgram 'Shock Experiments.'

 

Other such machinations demonstrate how our attitude towards ourselves and other human beings has been corrupted by this kind of spurious science which has so disasterously influenced our society and is still so prevelent in our world today.

 

Many examples of the counter arguments are given throughout the book which has no less than 54 pages of 'notes' or references. This gives us all the evidence we need to understand and celebrate the intrinsic goodness of human nature and the fact that human beings are essentially good people at heart. 

 

What are the key takeaways?

 

Apart from the '10 Rules to Live by' above, I would add the following insights that might be helpful in the situation we find ourselves in today, especially in the actions we are taking to live our own lives as free sovereigns from a community perspective.

 

  1. Human beings depend on and are motivated by our immediate and wider living environments, impacted by the quality of the air we breathe, the water we drink, the food we eat and other essential resources we need to live a healthy, happy and fulfilling life - in harmony with ourselves, each other and the natural world we so depend on.

  2. Human DNA is programmed to be flexible so that it can adapt to the environment we find ourselves in as babies in the womb and newborns through puberty and adulthood. The good news is that whatever we have suffered in the past can be fully and completely healed when we are exposed to a nurturing and supportive environment (or culture) at anytime in our lives.

  3. Human beings are particularly resourceful, compassionate and helpful towards each other during a crisis, quickly coming together to contribute skills, knowledge and information to help everyone come through the ordeal together.

  4. If a so-called based on true life story becomes a block-buster or goes viral it could be a clear sign that it may not be the truth but rather skewed to present the most unfavourable impression of human nature using Veneer Theory. This aligns very well with the last of my favourite '10 Rules to Live By' which is to 'avoid the news (and mainstream media)' as much as possible.

  5. Human beings are sociable animals which is something very well understood by our Indigenous friends and hunter-gather societies back in the days when, to be elected as leader for the tribe, you had to be:

 

Generous

Brave

Wise

Charismatic

Fair

Impartial

Reliable

Tactful

Strong

Humble

 

Sounds a lot like our champion Founding Facilitators who are working so hard to bring people together in their communities so that we too can demonstrate the beauty of humankind and how well we can learn to live, work and play together and take back control of our lives - without having to be managed by anyone - thank you very much.

 

 

Sue Cartwright AInstAM

Community Assembly of the British Isles

Editor


Further Reading


To 'Have' Or To 'Be' - Erich Fromm

The Wisdom of Wolves - Elli H Radinger

A Community Perspective - Sue Cartwright

Sowing The Seeds of Freedom -  Vandana Shiva

The Winning Ways of Togetherness - John Gilbert


Buy Online!


If you would like to read Humankind - A Hopeful History by Rutger Bregman, you can purchase the book in our Community Assembly of the British Isles bookshop using this affiliate link. Please note that if you make a purchase, we may earn a small commission on any books sold. Thank you for your support.


Sue Cartwright, Founder of Spiral Leaf & Community Assembly Facilitator for the Community Assembly Hub, Devon

About Sue


Sue is a writer, administrator, researcher, web designer and founder of Spiral Leaf sharing the beauty and abundance of Nature, Spirituality and Natural Health. 


Sue is Founding Facilitator of the Community Assembly of Devon, and editor/designer of the Community Assembly of the British Isles website and blog.

If you enjoyed this post, please share or forward to a friend - thank you!

Who's Jurisdiction - An Interview with Wiremu Williamson - Community Assembly of the British Isles
by Sue Cartwright 29 Mar, 2024
Bill Williamson, Emissary of People's Assemblies of New Zealand, shares his wisdom on the meaning of jurisdiction.
St Austell Peace Keepers in Action by John Gilbert, Community Assembly of the British Isles
by John Gilbert 29 Jan, 2024
A post about Community Peace Service training, our uniforms and the St Austell Community Peace Service team in action.
United We Stand For Humanity by Ana Isabel, Community Assembly of the British Isles
by Ana Isabel 27 Oct, 2023
An insightful post about current astrological influences and the benefit of uniting for each other, our communities and humanity.
The TEAM in Teamwork by Nick Kitchen, Community Assembly of Lincolnshire
by Nick Kitchen 21 Sept, 2023
A post about the importance of teamwork - working together as a team makes us stronger, safer and happier in the long run.
The Light Wave by Gayla Olson, Emissary , Community Assembly of America
by Gayla Olson 02 Sept, 2023
The Light Wave movement is a vision, an idea for a simple, easy-to-execute movement to support and further awakening.
Requirements For Change by Sue Cartwright, Spiral Leaf
by Sue Cartwright 30 Apr, 2023
Understanding resistence to change is the first step towards building a beautiful future for ourselves, our communities and humanity.
A Real Story of the Lord of the Flies by Sue Cartwright, Community Assembly of the British Isles
by Sue Cartwright 02 Apr, 2023
Beware of stories designed to alter our perceptions and question our self worth as innately resourceful, kind and considerate human beings.
Realising our vision though shared values by Sue Cartwright, Community Assembly of the Brit
by Sue Cartwright 24 Mar, 2023
Our foundational shared vision, mission and values are an important first step towards towards creating our ideal community culture.
No More Storms by Adrian Shaw, Community Assembly of Mevagissy
by Adrian Shaw 08 Mar, 2023
A poem about the magic of finding the calm within the storms that surge around us! Philosophical poetry by Adrian Shaw.
Creating a Community Assembly by Nick Kitchen, Community Assembly of Lincolnshire
by Nick Kitchen 08 Mar, 2023
We can learn so much from Nature as the ants and the bees know how to work together as one to help further their community.
More posts
Share by: